Separate and Divorce Without Court:
The Top 6 Reasons Why

Separating is hard. Court doesn't have to make it harder.

If you can resolve your family law matter without stepping foot in a courtroom, do it. Most families can. At Pathway Legal, we've spent decades helping BC families find their way through separation with less stress, less expense, and more dignity. Court is rarely the answer.

Here are the top six reasons why divorcing without court is almost always the better path.

At a Glance: 6 Reasons to Avoid Court

• Judges don't always get it right
• Life-changing decisions belong with you, not a stranger
• Court is expensive, often shockingly so
• The process takes a very long time
• Court is one of the most stressful experiences of your life
• Your private life becomes public record

Reason 1: Judges Don't Always Get It Right

Most judges are smart, experienced, and work hard to make fair decisions. In BC, the judicial appointment process is rigorous. Judges are assessed on their legal knowledge, fairness, temperament, and judgment.

But judges are human. And not all of them are great.

All of the lawyers at Pathway Legal have seen judges ignore the law, make wildly inconsistent rulings, and let personal bias slip into their decisions. In one case at our firm, a judge contacted a client at home, without her lawyer present, in a matter involving family violence. The call went badly. We filed a formal complaint and received an apology. But the damage to our client was already done.

That's the risk you take when you hand your future to a stranger in a courtroom.

There are times when court is necessary. If you're escaping family violence, or your ex refuses any form of dispute resolution, a judge may be your only option. But if there's any chance of reaching an agreement, take it.

Reason 2: Why Would You Let a Stranger Decide Your Family's Future?

Think about what a judge actually knows about your family when they walk into that courtroom.

• They don't know your children's personalities.
• They don't know what matters most to you.
• They don't know your family's rhythms, your values, or your history.
• They don't love your kids. You do.

You and your ex, even in the middle of a difficult separation, know your family far better than any judge ever will. That knowledge is a powerful tool. Use it to negotiate a solution that actually fits your life, rather than handing the decision to someone who will make a call and move on to the next file.

Reason 3: Court Is Expensive — Often Shockingly So

Legal fees add up fast when you go to court. For every hour of court time, your lawyer has spent at least as much time preparing: drafting documents, reviewing disclosure, preparing witnesses, strategizing.

In BC, court days are short. A typical day runs from 10 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. and 2 p.m. to 4 p.m., with breaks. A single issue can take five or more trial days. Multiply that across the legal fees for both parties, and you're looking at multiple tens of thousands of dollars, sometimes much more.

Mediation most often costs only a fraction of that. The money you save stays where it belongs: with you and your family.

Reason 4: Court Takes a Very Long Time

Booking a court date in BC requires coordinating your lawyer's schedule, your ex's lawyer's schedule, and the court's availability. As of writing this article, our courts are very backed up. They are not booking hearings until well into next year, and it is only March.

Then there's the wait. Courts routinely book more hearings than they have judges or courtrooms to handle. In BC, criminal matters take priority over family matters, which means your hearing can be bumped at the last minute, after you've waited months and paid for preparation. When that happens, you start the scheduling process all over again.

Meanwhile, your life might feel like it is on hold. Maybe it is on hold. Decisions about your kids, your home, and your finances are all waiting for a court system that is not built to move at your pace.

Out-of-court resolution lets you set your own timeline without having to worry about the court calendar.

Reason 5: Court Is One of the Most Stressful Experiences You'll Have

We don't say that to scare you. We say it because it's true and we want you to be prepared.

Court is formal. There are strict procedural rules. The atmosphere is adversarial by design: there is almost always a winner and a loser, and both parties usually spend significant time and money only to find out which one is which.

Mediation and other dispute resolution processes have stressful moments too. But they allow for creative solutions, flexibility, and privacy. You control the conversation. In court, you don't.

Reason 6: Your Private Life Becomes Public Record

Court proceedings in BC are open to the public. That means anyone can walk in and watch. Your financial situation, your parenting struggles, your relationship history: all of it can be aired in open court.

Depending on the circumstances, reporters can attend and publish what they hear. We've seen clients experience deep shame and re-traumatization when their most private moments became newspaper stories.

When you resolve your matter outside of court, your family's business stays your family's business.

When Court Really Is the Right Choice

We believe in resolution, but we're also honest. There are situations where court is the right — sometimes the only — option:

• You are escaping family violence and need immediate protection orders.
• Your ex has a personality disorder and refuses any form of reasonable negotiation.
• Your ex is hiding assets and only court-ordered disclosure will uncover them or protect them.
• Urgent interim orders are needed to protect your children's safety.

If you're in one of these situations, we'll go to court with you. Pathway Legal handles litigation when it's necessary. But we'll always make sure we have discussed and explored alternatives first.

Make an appointment

Office Hours
Mon to Thurs: 8:30 am - 4:30 pm
Fri: 8:30 am - 12:00 pm

Pathway Legal Law Corporation, Family Law Lawyers. All rights reserved Val Hemminger

Your Privacy  Legal Disclaimer SMS T&C's

Copyright © [2020] –

It is with our honour and gratitude that we live, work, and play on the traditional territory of the Coast Salish peoples–Sḵwx̱wú7mesh (Squamish), Stó:lō and Səl̓ílwətaʔ/Selilwitulh (Tsleil-Waututh) and xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam) Nations.