Can we separate but still live together in BC?

Yes. In British Columbia you can be separated and still share an address.

It happens far more often than people expect, and BC law makes room for it. We hear this question from folks right across the province.

You might be sleeping in the spare room tonight. You might be working out how to tell your kids. You might have run the numbers on two rents and come up short. Whatever brought you here, this is what separating under one roof means for you, what it does not mean, and how to protect yourself while you sort out the rest.

The short answer

There is no such thing as a “legal separation” order in BC. You do not file anything. You do not see a judge. You are separated when one of you decides the relationship is over, says so, and begins living like it is over.

Section 3(4) of BC’s Family Law Act says spouses may be separated despite continuing to live in the same residence. A court can look at two things as evidence: one spouse communicating an intention to separate permanently, and an action by a spouse that shows that intention.

So sharing a home does not cancel your separation. What it does is make your date of separation harder to prove later. That date carries more weight than most people realize.

Why so many BC families choose to live under the same roof despite ending their spousal relationship

There are many reasons you might stay in the same home after your relationship ends. Here are the circumstances we see most often when we help BC families with their legal matters:

• Financial constraints. Two households cost more than one. In much of BC, your budget stretches to one mortgage or one rent payment, but not two.
• Your children’s stability. You want the household to stay steady while you work out a parenting plan.
• The timing needs to be right. You are finishing a school year, waiting to list the home in spring, waiting on a job start date, or waiting on medical treatment.

If you and your former spouse are on reasonably amicable terms, staying under one roof for a while can be a sensible choice. There is nothing second-rate about making it.

What separation means under BC law

To be separated under BC law, you need three ingredients. Together they show that your spousal relationship is over. Here is what surprises people: the two of you do not both need to tick every box. Only one of you does.

• Intention. One of you reaches a settled conclusion that the relationship is over. It does not have to be mutual.
• Communication. That decision gets passed to the other spouse in words they can understand. Hints do not count. You have told them it is over, or your spouse has told you.
• Action. Your daily life starts to look different from how it looked when you were a couple.

What happens if you have tried to make the relationship work again?

Reconciliation attempts happen, and BC law allows for them. Under the federal Divorce Act, you can live together again for up to 90 days to try to reconcile without restarting the separation clock. Under the BC Family Law Act, you are not treated as separated if, within a year, you resume living together mainly to reconcile and do so for periods totalling 90 days or more.

If you are thinking about trying again, that is your call to make and nobody else’s. Know where the 90-day line sits before you move back in, so a hopeful few months does not quietly cost you your separation date. Spoiler alert: a separation date is like a snapshot in time where your assets and debt get divided from that date.

This can matter a lot for people.

What “separate lives, one roof” looks like day to day

If your former spouse denies that you separated and you end up in court, the judge looks at how you lived when “separated” not only where you live. The court weighs a number of factors and asks whether, taken together, the two of you were living separate and apart, or whether you hit a rough patch in a relationship and then carried on as usual.

Here is what we have seen provide evidence of separation in our clients’ matters:

• You have separate bedrooms, or a clear division of space within the home.
• Your sexual relationship has ended. Courts do consider this, although it is one factor among many and rarely decides the question on its own.
• You have separate finances. Each of you has your own bank account and pays your own bills, and you have ended shared spending that is not for the children or for maintaining the house itself.
• You no longer look after each other at home. You do your own laundry, cook your own meals, and run your own errands.
• You have separate social lives. You no longer attend events together as a couple.
• People know. Your family, your close friends, and your employer know that you are no longer together.

You do not need every item on this list. The more that are true, and the earlier they became true, the clearer your separation date is if it is disputed later.

Write the date down, then keep the copy

This is the single most useful thing you can do if you have any concern that your former spouse will one day deny you separated. Send them a short, dated message saying you consider the relationship to be over as of that date. Plain wording is fine. Keep a copy somewhere they cannot reach, such as a personal email account, or a printed copy left with someone you trust.

A disputed separation date can take a matter that should have been a straightforward negotiation and turn it into an expensive fight over calendars, text messages, and who slept where. Two minutes of typing now can save you thousands later.

More on why the separation date carries so much weight

• It affects how property and debt get divided. What counts as family property and family debt is measured up to the date of separation. Assets one of you brought into the relationship, along with certain gifts and inheritances, can be excluded property, while the growth in their value during the relationship is shareable. Separation is where that line gets drawn.
• It starts your time limits. Under section 198 of the Family Law Act, if you are unmarried (common law), you have two years from the date of separation to bring claims for property division, pension division, and spousal support. If you are married, you have two years from the date of your divorce order or annulment. Those limits are paused while you are engaged in family dispute resolution with a qualified family dispute resolution professional.
• It sets your divorce timeline. A divorce based on separation requires one year of living separate and apart, and you can spend that year in the same house. You can start the process before the year is up.
• It changes your benefits and taxes. Your marital status affects the Canada Child Benefit, the GST/HST credit, and who claims which credits for your children.

If you are common law, that two-year clock is the one that catches people out.

It starts on the date you separated, not on the day someone finally rents a truck.

The CRA piece, which trips up almost everyone

The Canada Revenue Agency runs its own test. For tax purposes, you are separated once you have been living separate and apart because of a relationship breakdown for at least 90 consecutive days. Once you pass the 90 days, your separation is recognized back to the first day of that period. You report the change using Form RC65, Marital Status Change, or through your CRA account.

Here is the reality of doing that from the same address. CRA looks harder at couples who share a mailing address, and you should expect to be asked to back up what you are reporting. Keep separate bank accounts, keep bills in your own name where you can, keep the dated message that set your separation date, and keep any written arrangement you and your spouse make about the household.

Your separation can be perfectly valid under BC family law and still be questioned by CRA. Two different tests, two different agencies, two different sets of consequences. Getting your marital status wrong can mean repaying benefits, so this one is worth a conversation with your accountant as well as your lawyer.

Your children

Your kids can handle a great deal when the adults are clear. They struggle when the message keeps changing. A few things that help:

• Tell them together, in plain words, once you have a basic plan. Not in the middle of a fight.
• Keep the parenting schedule real even inside one home. Who does bedtime, who does school pickup, who is on duty tonight.
• Never use your children as messengers, and never ask them to report on the other parent.
• Keep conflict out of shared space. Children read a room faster than adults think they do.
• Agree on how you will both describe the arrangement, so your kids hear the same story twice.
• You can discover more about telling your kids about separation here

Ground rules worth agreeing on in your first month

Sit down once, early, and sort out the practical stuff before it turns into a nightly argument:

• Sleeping arrangements, and which spaces are private.
• Who pays which bills, and out of which account.
• Groceries and household supplies, including whether you shop separately.
• The parenting schedule inside the house, written down like any other schedule.
• Guests and new partners in the home, and how much notice each of you gives.
• How you communicate about logistics. A shared app or a single email thread beats hallway conversations that turn into arguments.
• What happens to the home, and roughly when.
• A target date for having a final separation agreement in place.

Put it in writing, even informally. An interim household arrangement is not a final separation agreement, and it will keep the daily friction down while you work toward one.

When sharing a home is not safe

If there is family violence, if you are being threatened, or if you are frightened in your own home, this arrangement is not a workable plan and you should not try to make it one. In an emergency, call 911.

BC’s Family Law Act allows the court to make protection orders, and to grant you temporary exclusive occupancy of the family home under section 90. These applications can be brought quickly, and you do not need to have your whole future figured out before you ask for safety.

The mistakes we see most often

None of these are about being careless. They happen because life is loud and the paperwork feels like it can wait. Here is what to dodge:

• Keeping no written record of your separation date, and ending up with two very different memories a year later.
• Leaving your finances fully merged for months, which blurs the picture for both family law and CRA.
• Assuming your spouse knows it is over, when nothing was ever said out loud.
• Treating the arrangement as open-ended limbo, and letting a limitation period run out.
• A new partner turning up in the shared home with no conversation first, which turns a workable arrangement into a crisis overnight.
• Signing nothing, on the theory that it will all get sorted when the house sells.

Getting to a final separation agreement while you share a home

Living together does not put your matter on hold, and it should not. Most BC families reach a final separation agreement without ever seeing a courtroom, through negotiation between lawyers, mediation, or a collaborative process. If you mediate, we recommend you bring your lawyer with you, because the advice you get in the room is what makes an agreement hold.

Court is our last resort, and the timelines are part of the reason. A contested matter in BC runs many months, and often, years. As a general guide on cost, a simple uncontested divorce runs around $3,500, a negotiated or mediated resolution typically runs $7,000 to $20,000, and a collaborative process typically runs $10,000 to $30,000. Every matter is different, though.

The bottom line

 Separating under one roof is workable. You need three things: a clear date, clear handling of the money, and a plan with an endpoint. Get those right and the arrangement can protect your budget and your children while you sort out the rest.

Pathway Legal Law Corporation, Family Law Lawyers. All rights reserved Val Hemminger

Your Privacy  Sitemap  Contact Us  Legal Disclaimer  SMS T&C's

Copyright © [2020] –

It is with our honour and gratitude that we live, work, and play on the traditional territory of the Coast Salish peoples–Sḵwx̱wú7mesh (Squamish), Stó:lō and Səl̓ílwətaʔ/Selilwitulh (Tsleil-Waututh) and xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam) Nations.