Should I talk to a lawyer before I tell my spouse?

Yes, and it is not the sneaky thing you might be worried it is. One hour of advice before the conversation is one of the highest-value hours you will ever spend, and it protects both of you. We hear this question from folks right across the province, usually in a whisper.

You may have been turning this over for months. You may have picked a date to say something and then let it pass twice. Here is what a lawyer can give you before that conversation, what to avoid doing in the meantime, and how to have the conversation itself without setting fire to the next two years.

The short answer

Talking to a lawyer is information gathering. Nothing gets filed. Nothing gets served. Your spouse is not notified, and no clock starts running because you booked a meeting.

You are also not committing to anything. Plenty of people come to see us, get the lay of the land, and decide to stay and work on the marriage. That is a real outcome and a good one. Knowing what separation would actually look like is useful information either way.

What a first consultation actually gives you

Most people arrive thinking they need to ask whether they are allowed to separate. That is never the question. Here is what you actually walk out with:

• A realistic picture of your finances divided. What counts as family property, what might be excluded because you brought it in or inherited it, how your debts get treated, and what happens to your pension.
• Whether you are a spouse under the Family Law Act. If you are not married, this turns on how long you have lived together in a marriage-like relationship, and whether you have a child together. It changes what you can claim.
• Rough numbers on support. Child support follows the Federal Child Support Guidelines and is fairly predictable. Spousal support has ranges. You should know both before anyone says a number out loud.
• The truth about parenting. There is no default parent in BC. The law looks at your children’s best interests under section 37 of the Family Law Act, and the arrangements that work are the ones built around your actual family, not around what a neighbour told you.
• What to do and what to avoid in your first month.
• Whether your situation has a wrinkle that changes the order of operations. A business, a sponsorship or immigration application, property in another country, a disabled child, an inheritance you are expecting, or a safety concern.

Why the order of these conversations matters

The tone you set in that first conversation follows you for years. It shapes whether the two of you end up negotiating or litigating, and litigating in BC runs many months, and sometimes years.

That conversation also sets your date of separation, which is the date your property and debt get measured to and, if you are common law, the date your two-year limitation clock starts. Walking into it knowing that is worth something.

And most of the damage we clean up happens in the week after the conversation, not before it. Someone empties an account. Someone moves out in a hurry. Someone tells the children before there is anything to tell them. Advice beforehand is what keeps that week calm.

What not to do before you say anything

None of this is about being clever. It is about not handing your former spouse a grievance that costs you money later:

• Do not move money or empty accounts. Full financial disclosure is required in every BC family matter, so it will be seen, and a court can put it back. It also destroys the trust you will need to settle.
• Do not hide, delete, or destroy documents. Same reason, with worse consequences.
• Do not secretly record your spouse. It rarely helps your matter, it frequently damages it, and the rules around recording are narrower than people assume. Ask before you press record, not after.
• Do not tell your children until you have a plan for what happens next. They will ask where everyone is going to live, and you need an answer.
• Do not post anything about it. Screenshots last forever and get filed as exhibits.
• Do not sign anything your spouse puts in front of you, however reasonable it sounds in the moment.
• Do not move out without advice first. Leaving does not give up your interest in the property, and it can affect who lives in the home and the day-to-day parenting pattern that then becomes the status quo.

What to bring to your consultation

You do not need to have any of this perfect. The more of it you have, the more specific the advice can be:

• Your dates. When you started living together, when you married, your children’s birthdates.
• Income for both of you. The last three years of tax returns and notices of assessment, and recent pay stubs.
• A rough list of what you own and what you owe. Home and mortgage balance, vehicles, RRSPs, TFSAs, pensions, business interests, credit cards, lines of credit, student loans.
• What you brought into the relationship, plus any gifts or inheritances you received during it. This is the excluded property conversation, and it matters.
• Any agreements already in place. A marriage agreement, a cohabitation agreement, a previous court order, your wills.
• Your questions, written down. You will forget them otherwise. Everyone does.

If you are afraid of how your spouse will react

This changes the order of everything. Get advice before you say a word, and do not have the conversation alone in the home if you are frightened.

BC’s Family Law Act allows the court to make protection orders, and to grant you temporary exclusive occupancy of the family home under section 90. Those applications can be brought quickly and, where necessary, without notice to your spouse. In an emergency, call 911. For support and safety planning any time of day, VictimLink BC is 1-800-563-0808.

You do not need to have decided anything about your future to ask for help staying safe in the present.

How to have the conversation itself

There is no version of this that feels good. There are versions that go better:

• Pick your moment. Not at bedtime, not after either of you has been drinking, not in front of the children, not on a birthday.
• Keep it short and clear. This is not the moment for a list of everything that went wrong. A grievance list turns a hard conversation into a fight you then pay lawyers to continue.
• Say what you want next. Something like: I want us to sort this out fairly and without a war. That sentence does real work.
• Do not negotiate anything on the spot. Do not agree to numbers, dates, or who gets what. You can say you are not ready to talk about details yet.
• Expect disbelief. Many people need to hear it more than once before it lands, and the second conversation is often the real one.
• Have somewhere to go afterward. A friend, a walk, anywhere that is not the same four walls for the next three hours.

What if we want to keep this friendly?

Then advice first matters even more. Amicable separations do not fall apart because someone saw a lawyer. They fall apart when two people sign something neither of them understood, and one of them works out a year later what they gave up.

Once you have both had advice, there are good routes to a final separation agreement. Negotiation between lawyers, mediation, or a collaborative process. If you mediate, we recommend you bring your lawyer with you, because the advice you get while decisions are being made is what makes an agreement hold.

What a first meeting looks like, and what it costs

You talk, we listen, we ask about the things you did not think were relevant (they often are), and you leave with a plain-language picture of where you stand and what your options are. It is one meeting. You are not signing up for anything.

Our initial consultation comes with a money-back guarantee on the consultation fee. As a general guide on the bigger picture, a simple uncontested divorce runs around $3,500, a negotiated or mediated resolution typically runs $7,000 to $20,000, and a collaborative process typically runs $10,000 to $30,000. Every family is different, and we would rather tell you the range up front than surprise you later.

The bottom line

Seeing a lawyer before you tell your spouse is not a betrayal and it is not a declaration of war. It is how you walk into the hardest conversation of your life knowing what is fair, what is possible, and what not to do in the week that follows.

We work with families from our offices in Victoria, Nanaimo, Vancouver, and Surrey, and with clients right across British Columbia by video. There is a better path through this, and you are in good hands (and paws).

Pathway Legal Law Corporation, Family Law Lawyers. All rights reserved Val Hemminger

Your Privacy  Sitemap  Contact Us  Legal Disclaimer  SMS T&C's

Copyright © [2020] –

It is with our honour and gratitude that we live, work, and play on the traditional territory of the Coast Salish peoples–Sḵwx̱wú7mesh (Squamish), Stó:lō and Səl̓ílwətaʔ/Selilwitulh (Tsleil-Waututh) and xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam) Nations.